Retailers are being urged to strengthen their returns processes without making legitimate refunds harder for customers, as new research highlights the operational costs of return fraud and policy abuse.
Criminologists from Griffith University and The University of Western Australia led the study, which distinguishes between deliberate fraud, such as using fake receipts or returning stolen goods, and opportunistic behaviour such as wardrobing. In these cases, customers buy an item, use it once and then return it for a refund.
The findings show why retailers need different responses to each problem. Deliberate fraud calls for stronger verification and connected data, while opportunistic abuse requires clearer policies, consistent staff practices and customer education.
Returns misconduct adds to retail costs
Processing a return involves more than issuing a refund. Retailers must inspect returned products, assess their condition and prepare them for resale. Some items require repackaging or discounting, while others cannot be resold as new and may have to be written off. Each step adds cost and complexity as goods move back through the supply chain.
Wardrobing illustrates this challenge. Customers may assume retailers can simply resell an item after someone has used it, but that assumption overlooks the work required to inspect and process the product. Depending on its condition, the retailer may need to discount it or remove it from sale altogether.
The researchers also identified online communities where people share advice and methods for carrying out fraudulent returns. These networks allow offenders to exchange techniques and learn how to repeat deceptive practices, making it harder for retailers to identify suspicious claims.
The study combined a survey of 5,900 consumers across Australia, the United States, the United Kingdom and Canada with an analysis of online fraud communities and the methods people use to carry out returns misconduct. The researchers examined both customer behaviour and the processes that enable different forms of fraud and abuse.
Better data can help retailers target fraud
The researchers recommend that retailers establish three core capabilities before introducing stricter returns controls: stronger governance of returns policies, connected data from purchase through to refund, and better support for frontline staff.
By linking transaction and returns records, retailers can identify suspicious patterns and verify claims more effectively. They can then use stronger checks, risk scoring and clear escalation procedures to investigate suspected fraud and repeated deception.
However, retailers risk creating unnecessary friction if they treat every questionable return as the same problem. Broad restrictions can inconvenience customers with legitimate claims, while unclear rules and inconsistent enforcement can give opportunistic abuse room to continue.
Retailers can address these risks by giving staff clear guidance, applying policies consistently and explaining return conditions to customers. These measures help distinguish deliberate deception from behaviour that exploits ambiguous or overly generous policies, allowing businesses to target controls more effectively.
Protecting margins without undermining service
For retail and supply chain operations, the challenge is to balance loss prevention with a returns experience that customers can navigate easily.
Returns policies influence more than customer service. They also determine how retailers inspect, route and recover products before returning them to saleable inventory. Poorly managed processes can create unnecessary handling, reduce the value recovered from returned stock and add pressure to already complex retail operations.
The research points to a targeted approach. Retailers should connect data across the purchase-to-refund process, give frontline teams the guidance and support they need, and match their controls to the type of misconduct involved.
As product returns continue to create operational demands for retailers, distinguishing deliberate fraud from policy abuse could help businesses protect margins without penalising customers who make legitimate claims.
Also read: What happens after a product is returned?
Yvette is a Content Producer at Akolade, producing stories for Supply Chain Channel, an Australian learning ecosystem created to address the need for information, networking, case studies, and empowerment for everyone in the supply chain sector.

